Thursday, October 31, 2013

The Power of Pensive Recollection

“Daffodils”
I wandered lonely as a cloud
That floats on high o'er vales and hills,
When all at once I saw a crowd,
A host, of golden daffodils;
Beside the lake, beneath the trees,
Fluttering and dancing in the breeze.

Continuous as the stars that shine
And twinkle on the milky way,
They stretched in never-ending line
Along the margin of a bay:
Ten thousand saw I at a glance,
Tossing their heads in sprightly dance.

The waves beside them danced; but they
Out-did the sparkling waves in glee:
A poet could not but be gay,
In such a jocund company:
I gazed--and gazed--but little thought
What wealth the show to me had brought:

For oft, when on my couch I lie
In vacant or in pensive mood,
They flash upon that inward eye
Which is the bliss of solitude;
And then my heart with pleasure fills,
And dances with the daffodils. 
William Wordsworth


William Wordsworth was a renowned English romantic poet of the nineteenth century. His work was present in romantic works such as Frankenstein. “Daffodils,” also known as “I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud,” follows the narrator (who we can assume is Wordsworth) as he recalls his discovery of a field of wild daffodils at which he marvels without weighing the benefits they may bring him. The second half of the poem deals principally with his recollection of the beautiful daffodils and the happiness they bring him in his “pensive mood.” Like “Tintern Abbey” (one of his other famous works), “I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud” has a strong focus on nature, its impact on the narrator, and the power of recollection vs. immediate enjoyment. The first and most evident connection created by Wordsworth in the poem is that of man and nature. While the poem opens centered on the narrator as he floats “o’er the vales and hills,” it quickly shifts in focus to describe the field of daffodils. What is more significant is the extent to which Wordsworth personifies the flowers. He describes them as a “crowd,” “dancing” and “tossing their heads.” Meanwhile, the narrator himself is described as a cloud (i.e. not human). The “swap” of human and natural characteristics draws a strong connection between the narrator and nature around him.        

The choice of daffodils over any other specie of flowers is also important to investigate. Daffodils are also known as Narcissus. Narcissus, in mythology, was a Greek hunter who, upon seeing his reflection in a pool of water, fell in love with his own beauty and died as a result (either by drowning or starvation).  Not so coincidently, where he died grew a patch of narcissus (or daffodils). In the poem, the daffodils also grew by a body of water (“sparkling waves”), and the narrator is almost mesmerized by their intense beauty. It can be concluded that Wordsworth chose daffodils due to their connections to the myth of Narcissus, so that they would better express the intense passion experienced by the narrator, much like Narcissus did with his own reflection.


As with “Tintern Abbey,” this poem also has a strong focus on the power of recollection, rather than immediate appreciation. While the narrator experienced an intense appreciation for the flowers’ beauty, the poem places a strong emphasis on the strong feeling of pleasure/happiness that recollection of the daffodils bring to the narrator when he thinks back to the field. More precisely, there is a focus on recollection in a “pensive mood.” The narrator’s “inward eye” is his power of recollection and memory. The pleasure brought to the narrator through calm, pensive, recollection seems stronger and more powerful than his initial observation of the flowers, which appears more superficial. Recollection leads his “heart” to fill with pleasure. The heart is representative of a human being’s center, identity, and most importantly, soul. Therefore, when his heart fills with pleasure, it is a much stronger bond that is created than when he merely observes the outward beauty of the daffodils. It allows him to “dance with the daffodils,” and truly connect with nature.

Monday, October 21, 2013

Cain and Grendel

In Beowulf, we first learn that both Grendel and his mother are descendants of Cain. The novel, Grendel, then reveals that Grendel and Cain are in fact very similar characters and share similar attributes and mannerisms. The first, most blatant similarity is the disruption they cause to the idea of comitatus that was so central to Anglo-Saxon culture. Kinship, interlacing, and brotherhood were the center, and possibly most important aspects of Anglo-Saxon culture. Warriors went as far as going to war to avenge the (sometimes accidental) death of a kin. To Anglo-Saxons, kinship and brotherhood were not limited to actual blood relations, but instead extended to other members of their “tribe” or group. When Cain committed the sin of murdering his brother Abel, he performed the act that Anglo-Saxons would consider as the most hateful and outright evil crime conceivable. While Grendel does not murder his own kin in the novel, he disrupts the comitatus by forcing his way into the mead hall (a place of communion) and killing thanes.  There is also a strong focus on the blood of victims. In the bible, the earth is described as cursed to drink Abel’s blood. Eve even dreams that Cain is drinking Abel’s blood. In Grendel, the murders of thanes place a strong importance on blood. Grendel is found goring and drinking their blood. He even describes having dry blood in his fur. In literature, blood is strongly representative of life. It symbolizes the “essence” of life, and can either be used to represent the giving or life (as in birth), or the taking of life (such as in Grendel). It is therefore not surprising that such an emphasis is placed on blood, as both characters are renowned for killing and murdering. 
            Cain and Grendel are also similar in the fact that they are seemingly unable to die (at first, at least).  God marked Cain and condemned him to live on, threatening any man that the killing of Cain would in turn be punished seven times over. Until the arrival of Beowulf, no one was able to kill Grendel. No sword could hurt him and he walked the halls killing as he pleased without suffering consequences other than a stomachache.

The most important similarity, however, is that both Cain and Grendel are outcasts in their respective societies. After receiving the mark, Cain was forced into exile, as he could no longer farm the land that was not cursed by Abel’s spilled blood. His mark, a sign he displeased God, caused other men to stray away from him causing his isolation. Grendel is also a clear outcast in his society. He observes mankind from the forest. His figure is so horrid in appearance that even forest creatures run cower. With men running or attacking him on sight, forest animals cowering in fear, and his mother staring blankly not uttering a word, Grendel is as isolated as Cain was after his banishment. Grendel is therefore not simply a descendant of Cain, but in fact a more modern reincarnation of him.

Monday, October 7, 2013

The Connections Between Winesburg and a Love Song


Intertexuality is the "complex interrelationship between a text and other texts." (Merriam Webster Dictionary). A clear example of intertexuatlity recently discussed in class is the relationship between Anderson’s novel, Winesburg, Ohio, and T.S. Eliot’s poem, “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock.” The first of many connections that may be drawn is the organization on each text. Winesburg, Ohio is separated into almost independent short stories, which are only connected by George Willard, the central character in the novel. Eliot’s poem is similarly divided into separate, distinguishable sections. Each section works as part of a greater whole and is connected by the central character, J. Alfred Prufrock. Both works coincidently address a similar theme, supported by similar sub-themes. Both works primarily address the existential struggle of aging. At this point the two works begin to differ. Winesburg, Ohio focuses on a boy’s coming of age, while the poem addresses the shortness of life and its pending end. These differing subjects, however, connect due to the fact that each relays the author’s revelation through the common idea of death. Winesburg, Ohio opens with the story of an old writer (that is suspected to be George Willard). The old writer can feel his impending death fears that on any night he may die in his sleep. Similarly, a tired Alfred Prufrock nears death and seemingly accepts his coming end. In fact, it is up for debate, but it may be argued that Alfred told his love song while already dead. Death is used in both works to represent the inevitable passage that all human beings are bound to face, emphasizing the crucial need to thoroughly experience life before it ends. The second theme addressed in both works is the realization of inexistence we face as human beings. In Winesburg, Ohio, it is represented through George Willard’s coming of age and is presented by Anderson as maturity and “sophistication”. In Ellot’s poem, the theme is presented through Prufrock’s evident lack of confidence and resulting, self-inflicted, alienation from society. Prufrock compares himself to a scavenger scuttling along the seafloor, highlighting his lack of importance in the world. A smaller sub-theme that supplements the major themes in both works is the importance of communication, and the consequences of the inability to do so. The prime example in Winesburg, Ohio is Enoch Robinson. Enoch was “always a child” and unable to share his thoughts with anyone. This lack of communication led to the creation of his own imaginary world, which only reinforced his isolation from society. The day his imaginary friends left him, Enoch was left a purposeless wreck. Prufrock faced a similar barrier, as he was, for his entire life, unable to communicate his feelings with his “love”. This inability to form a connection led to his tragic downfall. The ending of Winesburg, Ohio, seems to indicate that connection is indeed the crucial component needed to avoid self-destruction. It was due to his silent but mutual connection with Helen White that George attained maturity and prepared to leave his hometown.

Sunday, September 29, 2013

The Love Song

T. S. Elliot’s poem, “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock,” begins with a short passage in Italian from Dante’s “Inferno”. The passage tells the tale of a damned man telling Dante his story in confidence, because he knows that it cannot be retold since all are trapped in eternal hell. Since the audience knows that this poem is in fact a love song, the introductory passage presents the idea that the love song is only told because its author believes that it will never be heard. This knowledge in combination with his odd name, begin to shape the personality the audience creates for Alfred Prufrock. The rest of the poem can be divided into seven distinct sections. Each section expresses the lamentation he feels because he did not act on his love. The poem begins romantically, with the evening “spread out against the sky,” but suddenly we find ourselves being led through “half-deserted streets.” Alfred continues to describe the filthy, polluted streets of a city we can infer is London (since T.S. Elliott lived in England). We can feel that at this point in the poem, Alfred is young. He constantly mentions having time ahead of him. He says that there is “time yet for a hundred indecisions.” He does not seem to be concerned about the future. He also appears to be avoiding some “overwhelming question,” leading us through the filthy streets of London rather than addressing the question. As we progress to sections three and four, Alfred is aging. He has a “bald spot” and his “arms and legs are thin!”. He has “measured out” life with “coffee spoons.” This metaphor is included to show he feels he has wasted his life away. The question he was trying to avoid at the beginning of the poem remains, and Alfred is growing more concerned. He tries to convince himself that “there is time” to go back, yet he is not capable to. The poem grows increasingly desperate. Alfred believes that he “should have been a pair of ragged claws, scuttling across the floors of silent seas.” In other words, he believes himself to be scavenger, who stays isolated and survives on others’ scraps. He now knows there is no more time. He laments all of the things that he should have done, but did not because he was “afraid.” The final section of the poem is where the audience fully faces Alfred’s low self-esteem and remorse. He hears mermaids on the beach, but does not believe that they will sing to him. He is insecure about his appearance, and still he grows older. Alfred regrets “having lingered in the chambers of the sea,” but by the time he woke up, he drowned. His whole life Alfred was “afraid” of a “thousand indecisions,” but by the time he was ready to face his “overwhelming question” it is too late. The time has passed, and all he has left is regret. I believe that this poem is more a confession than a love song. Alfred seems to be sharing his story as a way to relieve frustration he had trapped within himself his whole life.


Saturday, September 21, 2013

The Great Gatsby

I recently watched The Great Gatsby, some months after reading the book. While on its own the movie was good, I was struck by the differences between the novel and the movie. Many changes were made in the plot, which somewhat changed the emotions associated with it. The changes are evident from the very beginning of the movie. In the film, Nick has checked himself into a mental sanitarium for “morbid alcoholism.” While in the novel, Nick claims that he has been drunk “just twice” in his life, the movie shows him indulging in alcoholism far more than twice. Furthermore, while the novel discreetly implies hat Nick wrote The Great Gatsby (when Nick states that “Gatsby is the man who gave name to this book”), the movie goes further and shows Nick writing the story while at the Sanitarium, which takes away some of the original mystery of the novel.

The entire affair between Nick and Jordan that happens in the novel was cut out of the film. The beginning of the movie suggests that Nick and Jordan will start a relationship, but the matter is dropped and does not resurface for the rest of the film, leaving a loose end. In addition, Jordan is seen leaving on of Gatsby’s parties with another man, something that was not in the novel. Finally, in the movie, upon first meeting Jordan, Nick expresses that he finds Jordan frightening, a term never used in the novel.

Later, at Tom’s party, Nick waits in the living room while Tom and Myrtle loudly have sex in the bedroom. While this scene is implied in the novel, it is not nearly as explicit and central to that scene. When the party begins, Myrtle’s sister gives Nick a pill that she got from a doctor. This incident is never mentioned in the novel either. Finally, Nick wakes up home with no idea how he got there. In the novel however, Nick wakes up in on of he guests’ apartment and takes a train home.

Two characters were also completely omitted from the movie. In the novel, Nick has a maid, a Finnish woman who muttered to herself and made his bed. This decision was perhaps to emphasize how poor Nick is compared to his wealthy neighbors. While that is the same in the novel, the movie portrays Nick far more cash-strapped than is implied in the novel.  The second missing character is Ella Kaye; she is the woman who (in the novel) cheated Gatsby of Dan Cody’s fortune.

The final part of the plot, Gatsby’s death and funeral, were perhaps the most altered events. Gatsby’s death in the novel is not explicitly described; the audience only knows that Gatsby takes a pneumatic mattress into the pool and the chauffeur then hears the gunshots. In the movie, we see Wilson shoot Gatsby with a single shot to the back while he climbs out of the pool. Furthermore, the movie depicts Gatsby climbing out of the pool for a phone call, which he believes is from Daisy, while in fact it is Nick calling. This entire scene is not in the book and was added for drama in the movie. The funeral was also significantly “darkened.”  The attendance of Gatsby’s father and “Owl eyes” are also omitted from the film.


While most of these changes were minor, I found them particularly noticeable. While the altered “death scene” gives the audience comfort, knowing that Gatsby died thinking that Daisy chose him, it takes away from the colder feelings in the novel.