Monday, January 20, 2014

Why Hamlet and Grendel Should Become Friends


As we begin to read new novels and plays in class, it has become a subconscious habit for me to compare each new character to protagonists and antagonists of previous works. The same is the case with Hamlet, and as we analyzed Hamlet’s character traits in class, I could not help but notice as strong connection with John Gardner’s Grendel (the character). What first stood out to me was both characters’ isolation from their respective society. They both appear to be cast out for their difference. At the same time, however, they both evoke a sense of enlightened state. Whether it is through Grendel’s commentary, or Hamlet’s first soliloquy, both characters show signs of a deeper intelligence or awareness regarding their surroundings and those around them. This fact is especially apparent through their tendency to judge people. Grendel was notorious for watching the Danes, forming judgments about individuals’ characters. Similarly, Hamlet’s soliloquy reveals that he too is forming judgments. He compares Claudius to a satyr, not worthy of the throne, almost a disgrace when compared to his father, a sun god. He also judges his mother for re-marrying only two months after his father’s death, condemning her for her frailty and incestuous act. It is important to note that in both cases, we are allowed to see into each character’s mind while left to wonder about the deeper motives of others. Both characters are also severed from their respective parental figures. Grendel has no real father. As he comes to age and begins to explore, he falls victim to his curiosity. He is trapped in a twisted tree and is attacked by a bull and then by the animosity of man. At this point he loses the feeling of protection he once felt from his mother when he becomes aware of his alone-ness in the world. Hamlet’s father and idol is killed in battle. Two months later his mother re-marries and he loses all respect for her. While he still obeys her wishes (when she asks him to stay close), he is now unable to speak to her. Like Grendel, he too now finds himself robbed of parental figures on which he can rely. Hamlet can be perceived as a very sensitive character. He reacts strongly to emotions, as can be seen in the outrage of his soliloquy. This same trait is found with Grendel at a similarly early point in the novel, before he is introduced to the dragon’s nihilism. Grendel too was a highly emotional character, sometimes compared to an angry teen throwing fits.  Finally, the greatest similarity between Grendel and Hamlet is found in the nature of their conflicts. Both characters are faced with a strong inner conflict that is at the center of their anger and isolation. Of course, at only the third scene of the first act out of five, it is still very early in Hamlet to make such a heavy judgment on his character. My observations will likely be contradicted in many ways as we penetrate further into the play. We will just have to find out!

Sunday, January 12, 2014

A Poison Tree by William Blake

I was angry with my friend:
I told my wrath, my wrath did end.
I was angry with my foe:
I told it not, my wrath did grow.

And I watered it in fears,
Night and morning with my tears;
And I sunned it with smiles,
And with soft deceitful wiles.

And it grew both day and night,
Till it bore an apple bright.
And my foe beheld it shine.
And he knew that it was mine,

And into my garden stole
When the night had veiled the pole;
In the morning glad I see
My foe outstretched beneath the tree. 
William Blake

            Written by William Blake, “A Poison Tree” was published in 1794. The poem was part of the Songs of Experience, the collection of poems that followed (and contrasted) Blake’s Songs of Innocence. The narrator of the poem remains anonymous throughout the length of the poem. By withholding any traits of the narrator, Blake allows the poem to connect with the audience by being able to place himself or herself in the position of the narrator. The poem is a strong representation of the experienced and knowledgeable side of Blake’s poetry. Unlike the innocence that Blake would traditionally associate with youth, the narrator of “A Poison Tree” is in touch with the emotions he experiences. The narrator contrasts two conflicts he has experienced. In one, he told his friend of his anger and so the conflict ended. This conflict serves as a contrast for the second one, in which the narrator chooses not to reveal his wrath to his “foe,” leading to a disastrous result.

In the first line of the second stanza, the narrator mentions watering the wrath “in fears.” The close association of fear and anger is most likely meant to serve as an example of the destructive power they can have when combined in wrath. The narrator “sunned” his wrath “in smiles,” showing that he slowly let the wrath grow within him. He hides it with “deceitful wiles.” The narrator, who previously appeared to be the victim of his anger and fear, now becomes the perpetrator. The wrath can be perceived as the poison from the poem’s title, that is slowly corrupting a previously innocent narrator. This shift follows the traditional transformation presented in Blake’s poetry.


Blake continues the extended metaphor of the wrath’s growth portrayed as a poisonous plant into the third stanza. The narrator’s wrath does not stop growing until it produces an apple. The fruit is important for several reasons. The presence of the fruit means that the plant (and the wrath) have come to the final stage of their growth/ development. Fruits are also representative of sweetness and pleasure, indicating that the poisonous wrath may have corrupted the narrator to the point of enjoyment. The apple is a clear biblical allusion to the story of Adam and Eve. In this case, the apple (representative of the narrator’s wrath) becomes a temptation for his foe. The foe comes for the apple and is apparently killed as a result. It can be inferred that the “foe” was murdered by the narrator. By going back to the first stanza, the audience can see the contrast the author draws between the two conflicts. The conflicts serve as two distinct experiences by the narrator, both of which follow different outcomes of human nature. The first conflict demonstrates that by being open to emotions and communication, one is able to surmount the wrath and proceed with their life. In the second case, however, the lack of connection with his wrath leads to the growth of the apple-bearing “poison tree” and eventually results in the narrator, who was once only victim to his angers and fears, murder another being.

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Final Reflection

As this is my last blog for the first semester, it is now time to reflect on what has been learned, achieved, and what is left to strive for this upcoming semester.  When I finished AP Language Arts and signed up for AP Literature, I was honestly not sure what to expect. I loved to read, but I knew that writing was my Achilles’ heal and that there would be plenty of it in AP Literature. For this reason, I had made it a personal goal to work on my writing skills as much as possible so that I could confidently leave high school being not only a more effective reader, but also a more effective writer.

When the year began, my reading skills quickly showed signs of improvement. The novel Frankenstein fascinated me, making it a joy to “close read” every chapter. The online forum that was set up for summer reading assignments also helped me learn what to look for and allowed me to gain new knowledge and perception while also being able to share my findings. Covering such a wide variety of novels (and plays), from The Age of Innocence to the series of short stories in Winesburg, Ohio, truly helped me broaden my previously stagnating literary collection. The area that I gained the most skill in is that of close reading. This semester of AP Literature has helped me realize how much more there is to read in between the lines of novels that I had previously found mundane. Of course, practice has also helped me read faster which I am sure will turn out to be quite useful in college. For college, however, I would also have to be a good writer.

The beginning of the year proved to be a difficult time for me as a writer. For the first few timed writings, I will admit that I was at a complete loss. I was often unsure what the question asked, and how I should go about structuring my answers. The results were often disappointing, with oddly sized paragraphs that poorly reflected my reading of the novel. Organization, however, was the first aspect of my writing that began to improve. I quickly found out that (for me), the trick was to structure and organize each paragraph before writing the essay. While almost all of my timed writings lacked a formal pre-write, most have some sort of web or diagram that shows the basic structure of my essay. The area in which I struggled most (and still do) is that of analysis. I often fail to follow the basic “claim, data, warrant” structure because I lack the warrant. The comments left on my essays most commonly include “lack of analysis,” “go deeper here,” and “why?”


For the reasons mentioned above, my main goal next semester will be to stay focused on my writing. While I will still practice my reading skills with assigned readings, the bulk of my effort will go towards providing better analysis and going deeper in my essays. Remaining a competent reader is crucial because there can be no analysis without having a solid reading of the text.

Saturday, December 14, 2013

A Doll's House Foils

Like most literary works, A Doll’s House includes several character foils that help contrast one another. The two most notable foil pairs are Torvald and Krogstad, and Nora and Kristine. In both cases each character should be expected to occupy a similar role in society, but instead sharply contrasts the other morally and physically.

Torvald and Krogstad are both middle-aged males. They were childhood friends that were well acquainted. However, in their present situation, Torvald is the new high-placed manager at the bank while Krogstad works an insignificant position under Torvald’s command. A job is representative of social standing so one can initially see that Torvald is meant to contrast Krogstad in their positions in society. Torvald has a well settled home with Nora and the children she bore him; Krogstad was left by Kristine years prior and is alone. Torvald adheres strictly to gender roles and abhors anything that is not “beautiful,” while on the other hand, Krogstad does what he needs to survive and feed his children. These foil traits help the audience picture the characters as Ibsen would want them to. For instance, Torvald’s high position and stellar home indicated that he is very pre-occupied with appearances and his reputations in society. He works for what he was taught was the ideal life and refuses to accept that it is correct for one to overstep legal boundaries for something as petty as emotion and the greater good. Krogstad, however, is more willing to do what is necessary to survive. He cheats the law not because he wants to, but because he believes that it is necessary to bend the rules if it means being able to feed his children.

Nora and May are similarly foils. They are similar in the fact that they are both middle-aged women in a male-oriented society. They both had to make sacrifices to “save” the ones they love. Nora had to work to repay the loan that saved Torvald and Kristine had to leave her lover to marry to be in better financial standing. After this, however, come significant polar differences that create the foil. Throughout the play, Nora is representative of the “inside.” She symbolizes the home life of the 19th century woman. She represents protection, safety, youth, and innocence. Kristine, meanwhile, is a symbol of the “outside” world. She is often described as being dressed in a travel or outdoor coat. Unlike Nora, Kristine represents experience and wisdom. The common association of innocence/experience can be felt through the tangible difference in age between Nora and Kristine. Despite being the same age, it feels as though Kristine is much older, almost like Nora’s mother. This relationship is reminiscent of William Blake poetry on innocence vs. experience.


Ibsen’s inclusion of these foils served the important function of emphasizing each character’s traits through contrast. When in the same scene as Kristine, Nora appeared even more child-like and innocent. Similarly, Krogstad’s character helped exemplify the importance Torvald places on public appearance and social values.

Sunday, December 8, 2013

The Antagonist in A Doll's House

An interesting point that was raised during the class seminar on A Doll’s House Friday was if the play had an antagonist, and if it does, who would it be. An antagonist is a character who negatively affects another directly or indirectly purposefully. The initial character that I would have chosen as the antagonist would have been Krogstad. On first impression, he appears to possess all of the traits of an antagonist. He blackmails Nora and appears to have no respect for the happiness of others. Doctor Rank even went as far as referring to Krogstad as a “moral invalid.” However, by reading further into the play, it becomes apparent that Krogstad is only acting out of grief and necessity. He had mouths to feed and had been cheated by life when Kristine left him to marry a richer man. At the end of the novel, he even decides to remove his letter from Torvald’s mailbox (and Kristine stops him from doing so). After the scandal surfaces, he even goes as far as to return the only leverage he would have had to regain his position at the bank by giving back Nora’s note. It is for these reasons that Krogstad cannot be considered the antagonist of the play.


As we discussed during the seminar, the main problem or conflict in A Doll’s House is with doubt the “doll house condition” that surrounds Nora’s home life; it is what pushes her to leave at the end of the play. Logically, the antagonist would therefore most likely be the one responsible for that. One would be quick to place the blame on Torvald. After all, he physically perpetrates the condition. He calls Nora nicknames such as his “little lark,” and his “little squirrel.” To him, she is a “helpless little creature.” He constantly acts condescendingly towards Nora by wanting to “save” her whenever possible. However, in the 19th century, these were the accepted gender roles in society. Torvald is therefore only acting in the matter that would have been correct in the time period. It is not objective to judge his notions of gender roles by today’s standards. Nora can also easily be blamed because she not only lets the condition remain, but she even partakes in Torvald’s games by purposely asking for help and answering him as if a child were speaking. She says she “should not think” of going against Torvald’s “wishes.” She, herself, creates situations that are not above moral reproach. She openly flirts with Dr. Rank by titillating him with her silk stocking and promising to dance for him. However, while she constantly attempts to avoid the consequences rather than addressing the problem, she is still not antagonistic in nature; I would consider her more of an anti-hero (which is a whole other discussion).

My belief, is that Ibsen purposely left the play void of a true antagonist. Rather than having one character pitted against another, he has an individual pitted against the traditional values and expectations that surround her. This structural choice emphasizes the conflict of the individual versus the many that is at the center of this play. In this way, the audience can perceive that it is not one individual that must be punished, but rather the entire society that must be altered.